Bridging Data Silos: How Identity Resolution and CDPs Are Transforming Marketing Attribution

Marketing teams today face a frustrating paradox: they have more data than ever, yet struggle to accurately attribute results to the right channels. In fact, only 18% of marketers feel very confident in their attribution data, with a vast 82% reporting only partial clarity on what’s driving app installs and conversions. This “measurement blindness” isn’t due to lack of effort or talent – it’s rooted in fragmented tools and disconnected data that make it nearly impossible to get a full picture of the customer journey. The good news is that emerging solutions like identity resolution and Customer Data Platforms (CDPs) are helping marketers finally crack the attribution puzzle.

Ready to implement? Check out our 90-Day CDP Launch Plan for a practical roadmap to deploy Segment, Amplitude, and AppsFlyer with conversion APIs.

The Cross-Channel Attribution Struggle

Modern customers interact with brands across a maze of devices and platforms. Consider this: the average U.S. household now operates 22 internet-connected devices – from phones and laptops to tablets, smart TVs, and wearables. A single user might discover your product through a mobile ad, sign up on a desktop web app, then later make purchases in a native mobile app. Traditional tracking methods, which often treat each device or channel in isolation, simply can’t keep up with this reality.

At the same time, privacy changes and tech limitations have created new blind spots. Apple’s App Tracking Transparency (ATT) framework, for example, means only ~25% of iOS users opt in to share their device ID for advertising, leaving 75% of iOS users “invisible” to traditional tracking. Major browsers are phasing out third-party cookies, further fragmenting how we follow user journeys. The result? Marketers are often forced to piece together a customer’s path with incomplete data, like trying to solve a jigsaw puzzle with missing pieces.

It’s no wonder 80% of marketers are dissatisfied with their ability to reconcile results from all their different analytics and ad platforms. Nearly one-third of marketers say they cannot see the full picture of digital performance because data sits in silos across disconnected tools, making end-to-end journey tracking difficult. One dashboard might show a conversion came “direct” on web, while another system credits it to a Facebook ad – and neither connects to revenue in your CRM. This fragmentation erodes trust in the data. (How can you confidently allocate budget when you’re not sure which channel truly drove conversions?) It also leads to wasted spend, as teams double-count or miss attribution, and struggle to optimize campaigns based on real ROI. In fact, marketers rank better data as a top need – 40% believe that more accurate, unified data would improve their campaign reporting and decision-making.

Why Data Silos Persist (And Hurt Marketing Performance)

Most companies don’t set out to create data silos – they arise naturally as the marketing tech stack grows. You might use Google Analytics or Mixpanel for website analytics, a separate mobile attribution tool like AppsFlyer for app installs, a CRM for customer info, and perhaps a BI tool like QuickSight or Excel for revenue reporting. Each system generates its own user IDs and tracking cookies, which often aren’t linked to one another. As a result, the same person looks like multiple “users” across these platforms – one anonymous web visitor, one app install, one email lead – unless you find a way to stitch them together.

Data silos also produce discrepancies in metrics. It’s common to see internal product analytics showing different conversion counts than Facebook or Google Ads do. In one study, 80% of senior marketers admitted they struggle to even “patch together” a comprehensive view from all their measurement tools. And 28% of marketers say data silos prevent them from viewing channel performance holistically. When your attribution is fragmented, it’s hard to know which half of your marketing spend is truly working. Teams may resort to manually exporting data to spreadsheets – indeed, 42% of marketers still report attribution in spreadsheets as a workaround – but this is labor-intensive and error-prone.

All of this has a real cost. Marketing decisions based on siloed or imprecise data mean missed opportunities and inefficient budget use. On the flip side, companies that solve cross-device and cross-platform measurement see huge gains. Research shows that effective cross-device insights can lower cost-per-action by 30–50% and boost marketing ROI by 50–100%. Those are game-changing improvements – often the difference between an unprofitable campaign and a scalable one. Clearly, closing the data gaps in the customer journey is not just a tech project, but a strategic imperative for growth.

Identity Resolution: The Missing Link in Attribution

So how do we connect the dots? The answer is identity resolution – a fancy term for a simple idea: linking all of a customer’s interactions to a unified profile. In practice, identity resolution is the process of gathering customer data from all touchpoints and using it to build a single, unified view of the user. Instead of treating that mobile visitor on Monday and the desktop purchaser on Friday as separate people, we merge those records (when we have enough evidence they’re the same person) into one profile. This gives marketers a true 360-degree view of customer behavior across devices and channels.

How does identity resolution work? There are two main approaches:

Deterministic matching: using hard identifiers that are the same across contexts. For example, when a user logs in with the same email on your website and your mobile app, you can deterministically know it’s the same person. Other deterministic IDs include account IDs, loyalty numbers, or a universal user ID your system assigns upon sign-up. Deterministic matches are very accurate (like using a unique fingerprint), but require the user to identify themselves or use the same device consistently.

Probabilistic matching: using algorithms to infer a match based on patterns. For instance, if you see one anonymous user on a laptop in California and an anonymous mobile user in the same city, with the same browsing habits and overlapping session times, you might guess they’re the same person. Probabilistic identity resolution looks at factors like IP addresses, device type, operating system, and behavior patterns to stitch profiles with statistical probability. It casts a wider net (capturing cases where the user didn’t log in), but with less certainty than deterministic methods.

Advanced identity systems often combine both approaches: grab the deterministic links where available (e.g. the user logs in), and use probabilistic models to connect the rest. The goal is to maximize both coverage and accuracy – to recognize as many customer touchpoints as possible, while keeping false matches to a minimum.

For marketers, investing in identity resolution pays off by revealing the true customer journey. Suddenly, you can attribute that mobile ad to an eventual desktop purchase, because your system knows it’s the same person. In fact, cross-device identity can uncover that your “15% mobile conversion rate” is misleading – many mobile visitors convert later on desktop, which you’d see once those identities are merged. By stitching sessions together, you get credit where it’s due: the mobile campaign that initiated interest can be properly valued for the sale that happened elsewhere.

Just as importantly, a unified customer view lets you personalize marketing and product experiences. When you know that User A on desktop is the same as User B on mobile, you won’t retarget them with ads for the product they already bought in-app. You can sequence messaging across channels more intelligently. And you can analyze cohort behavior with confidence, seeing how different user segments engage over time across touchpoints. All of this leads to smarter spending and better customer relationships.

Enter the CDP: A Single Source of Truth for Customer Data

Achieving identity resolution might sound complex, but you don’t have to build it from scratch. This is where a Customer Data Platform (CDP) comes in. A CDP is a software platform (typically cloud-based) that collects, unifies, and distributes customer data for you. Think of it as an intelligent data pipeline: instead of each app or site sending data to siloed tools, everything funnels first through the CDP. The CDP then does the heavy lifting of matching user identities and forwarding the right data to all your marketing and analytics destinations.

For example, Segment (Twilio Segment) is a leading CDP that many growth-oriented companies use. With Segment, you instrument your website, mobile app, and server events once, using their SDKs or API. Segment will capture key events (page views, sign-ups, purchases, etc.) along with user identifiers (like device IDs or emails when available). It then resolves identities behind the scenes – using deterministic checks (has this device later logged in as an existing user?) and other logic – to maintain a consistent user ID as much as possible across platforms. Segment’s identity resolution feature (called Unify) deterministically merges profiles across devices when identifiers match, so you don’t end up with five profiles for what is actually one person.

Once the CDP has unified profiles and event data, it routes that data out to your various tools. This is often called “reverse ETL” or simply destination integration. In Segment’s case, you can turn on integrations with dozens of marketing and analytics platforms – from Google Analytics and Facebook Ads to CRMs and data warehouses. Segment will send the relevant events and user attributes to each platform in the format it expects. The beauty is you no longer need to instrument each tool separately. You track events once, and the CDP handles the fan-out.

This unified pipeline yields consistent data everywhere. Your Facebook Pixel and Google Analytics will finally count conversions in the same way, because the event came through a single source of truth. Moreover, because the CDP attaches a stable user identifier, your downstream tools can receive that and better reconcile cross-device actions. For instance, if Segment knows that anonymous web user 123 and mobile device ABC are actually the same user ID 555 after a login, it can send that unified ID to Amplitude or Mixpanel – which then merges the profiles on their side as well.

Critically, a CDP also allows you to use first-party data collection methods that preserve data in an era of privacy restrictions. Instead of relying solely on third-party cookies or external ad pixels (which are increasingly blocked), you can use your own domain and servers to collect behavioral data. Many CDPs support server-side tracking and use of your domain for cookie placement, which can significantly improve data capture (often recovering 10–37% more events) that would have been blocked by browsers or ad-blockers. In short, you regain control of your customer data in a privacy-compliant way – and ensure that less of it “falls through the cracks” due to technical blockers.

Turning Unified Data into Insights with Analytics Tools

Implementing a CDP and identity resolution sets the stage, but marketers still need to analyze and act on the unified data. This is where a platform like Amplitude comes in as a powerful companion to Segment. Amplitude is a modern analytics tool purpose-built for product and user behavior analysis, and it excels at leveraging a unified dataset. In fact, Amplitude has invested heavily in identity resolution on its own platform – it automatically merges anonymous and logged-in user records and can even retroactively join past activity once a user identifies themselves.

By feeding Segment’s cleaned, de-duplicated event stream into Amplitude, marketers get a clear window into the customer journey. You can build funnels that track users from the first ad click or website visit all the way through to sign-up, onboarding, and repeat purchases, even if those steps happened on different devices. You can see cohort retention (e.g. do users acquired from Channel X stick around longer or monetize better than those from Channel Y?). You can also zoom in to a single user’s timeline in Amplitude and literally see every touchpoint unified – an anonymous browsing session, an ad campaign parameter, the moment they signed up (tying the anonymous ID to their new profile), and subsequent in-app actions. This kind of insight is incredibly hard to achieve without robust identity resolution; with it, it becomes almost plug-and-play.

Amplitude further allows you to integrate marketing attribution data for even richer analysis. For example, it has a native integration with AppsFlyer, a mobile attribution provider, to pull in campaign source data. With that, you could analyze how users from a specific Facebook Ad campaign behave inside your product (do they complete the KYC step? do they deposit funds? which features do they use most?). This bridges the traditional gap between “marketing metrics” and “product analytics.” When your data is unified, the artificial wall between acquisition and engagement falls away – you can optimize for true lifetime value, not just initial conversion.

Finally, a unified data approach empowers better optimization of marketing spend. When you trust your attribution, you can confidently ramp up the channels and campaigns that yield high-value users. Also, by sending conversion and revenue events back to ad platforms via the CDP (for instance, piping purchase events into Facebook or Google as offline conversions), you help the ad platforms’ algorithms optimize for the outcomes that matter, not proxy clicks. This closes the loop: your analytics not only inform internal decisions, but also improve targeting externally by leveraging the same single source of truth.

Implementing Your Unified Data Strategy

Making this all work does require planning and technical implementation, but it’s more achievable than it might sound:

1. Define Key Events and IDs: First, align your team on what user actions and attributes are critical to track (sign-ups, KYC verifications, deposits, transactions, etc.). Ensure you have a way to capture a unique user identifier (like a login ID or email) whenever possible. Also plan for events that mark important funnel stages (e.g. “Application Submitted” or “Funds Deposited”).

2. Instrument via a CDP: Implement a Customer Data Platform such as Segment. Install the Segment SDKs in your web app and mobile app, and use it to track the events defined above. Segment will handle generating an anonymous ID for each new user and later associating it with a user ID once the user logs in or identifies. Double-check that your development team installs Segment (or your chosen CDP) before other analytics scripts, so it can mediate data collection.

3. Set Up Identity Resolution Rules: In your CDP settings, review how identity merging is configured. For instance, Segment allows you to decide when an anonymous profile should merge into an identified profile (usually upon a login event). Configure deterministic merges (by user ID or email) and consider if you will use any probabilistic matching features. The goal is to ensure that as soon as a user authenticates or provides identifying info, all their past actions tie to their profile going forward.

4. Connect Destinations: Use the CDP’s integrations to connect all the tools you need – analytics platforms (Amplitude, Mixpanel, Google Analytics), advertising platforms (Facebook, Google Ads, Twitter), attribution tools (AppsFlyer, Adjust), and databases or CRM. This typically is as simple as flipping a switch and providing your account API keys for each service. Going forward, Segment will forward your event data to each service in real time. For example, a “Sign Up Completed” event could be sent to Amplitude (for internal analysis), to Facebook Ads (as a custom conversion for ad optimization), and to your CRM (to trigger a welcome email campaign), all from the one event trigger.

5. Validate and Iterate: After implementation, spend time auditing the data flow. Do a few test user journeys and verify that the events show up correctly in all tools. Check that user counts match up (e.g. the number of sign-ups tracked in Amplitude equals the number in your database). It’s normal to find minor discrepancies – some users will opt out of tracking, or certain browsers might block scripts – but you should see a dramatic improvement in consistency. Over time, continue refining your tracking plan. Add new events as needed, and use your analytics to identify any drop-offs in the funnel where you might need better instrumentation.

By following these steps, marketers and developers collaborate to build a reliable marketing data foundation. This upfront work pays dividends in every campaign that follows. Instead of guessing or operating on partial data, you’ll be able to trust what your analytics are telling you about user acquisition and behavior.

The Payoff: Clear Attribution and Smarter Growth

When attribution woes are solved, marketers can finally focus on strategy rather than squabbling over whose data is “right.” A unified customer view means no more crediting the wrong channel or losing track of users who switch devices. You’ll know, for example, that the 10% of users who drop off after clicking an email later converted via retargeting – and you can adjust your spend accordingly. You’ll see that while Google Ads drove more sign-ups, Facebook Ads brought in users who retain 2x longer – insights that are only visible when lifetime events are connected to the acquisition source.

The broader industry is quickly recognizing this need for unified data. In a recent survey of large companies, only 8% reported having a full view of marketing performance across channels – but those few are reaping huge benefits. As tools mature, more organizations are closing the gap: the global CDP market is growing ~40% annually as businesses invest in first-party data solutions. Marketing attribution has evolved from last-click wins to multi-touch models, and now to an understanding that without identity resolution, even the best models fall short. It’s telling that two-thirds of marketers today worry about how to build durable measurement solutions in this changing landscape. The solution lies in embracing new approaches and platforms designed for this exact challenge.

By implementing identity resolution and a CDP, marketers transform attribution from a source of stress to a source of strength. They gain the ability to optimize campaigns with confidence, personalize user experiences in real-time, and prove – with data – the ROI of every marketing dollar. Instead of wrestling with fragmented reports, marketing teams can spend time on creative strategy and testing new ideas, knowing that the analytics will accurately capture the outcomes.

In summary, breaking down data silos is not just an IT project; it’s mission-critical for marketing success in 2025 and beyond. With the right approach, you can turn a messy tangle of touchpoints into a coherent narrative of each customer’s journey. And when you do, the rewards come quickly: lower acquisition costs, higher conversion rates, and marketing insights that truly drive the business forward. The path to get there – through identity resolution and CDPs – is increasingly well-trodden, and now is the time for marketers to take it. Your data wants to tell you the full story; you just need to give it the platform to speak.